Marcelli: where would we be without him? With the likes of Capoferro, probably - which just happened to whoever doesn’t understand Italian. Yet even the nasty Roman master had his small defaillances. He forgot some bit of knowledge here and there, and muddled the waters with a salvo of confusing nomenclatures. Soh, here we go:
- Marcelli explains stepping, but only regarding forward motion, not how you retreat. Except when you really Retreat™, with two quick steps.
- Marcelli never explains hand positions, and only cites Terza, Quarta and seconda in this order. Then as if nothing had happened, he proceeds to explain his guards, which are Prima, Seconda and Terza, and are unrelated to the hands position. In particular he doesn’t care at all that his Prima Guardia is kept with a hand in “Mezza Quarta” - you know what he means, don’t you? Did you get this? He doesn't care! Let’s keep going with his right Scanzo di Vita, which is normally called Inquartata, but which he calls sometimes the “Quarta”. He does it, I swear. Finally the prima position of the hand is never mentioned in all his book.
- Marcelli performs two different Botte Dritte. The one in the Spada Sola book is conventional, the one in the Spada e Daga is done with straight legs. Some elements make you suspect that this was normal for any style in his forebear Titta Marcelli’s time.
- Marcelli doesn’t care if you have a left hand. “Play it in the hair at your most pleasurable convenience”. I reasoned it out that he wants you to keep it behind your body to be completely profiled.
- Marcelli advocates a lunge that keeps the upper body straight. Yet he shows at least an image with a fencer succesfully lunging with a forward-inclined breast, and makes no mention about it. Why? I think that Marcelli approves of bringing forward your chest if you are to hit a lower target, just like what happens with his Sbassata. The reason is geometry, of course. In that image, indeed, it could be surmised that the fencer has feinted to the face and lunged to the lower torso.
I love him so much! This post is compiled from an
older one I wrote in Italian.